00a0Round table: \Problems of formation and implementation of the participatory budget in Kherson\

Democracy Reporting Inteational u0443 u0441u043fu0456u0432u043fu0440u0430u0446u0456 u0437 u0412u043eu0441u0442u043eu043a SOS u043fu0440u043eu0432u0435u043bu0438 u043au0440u0443u0433u043bu0438u0439 u0441u0442u0456u043b u043du0430 u0442u0435u043cu0443 u041fu0440u043eu0431u043bu0435u043cu0438 u0444u043eu0440u043cu0443u0432u0430u043du043du044f u0456 u0440u0435u0430u043bu0456u0437u0430u0446u0456u0457 u0433u0440u043eu043cu0430u0434u0441u044cu043au043eu0433u043e u0431u044eu0434u0436u0435u0442u0443 u0432 u0425u0435u0440u0441u043eu043du0456. 

n

u041du0430u0433u0430u043bu044cu043du0456u0441u0442u044c u0434u0430u043du043eu0457 u0442u0435u043cu0438 u0437u0443u043cu043eu0432u043bu0435u043du0430 u043du0435u0432u0438u0440u0430u0437u043du0438u043c u0440u043eu0437u0432u0438u0442u043au043eu043c u0456u043du0441u0442u0440u0443u043cu0435u043du0442u0443 u0431u044eu0434u0436u0435u0442u0443 u0443u0447u0430u0441u0442u0456 u0443 u0425u0435u0440u0441u043eu043du0456 u0442u0430 u0437u043du0430u0447u043du0438u043cu0438 u043fu0440u043eu0431u043bu0435u043cu0430u043cu0438,u0437 u044fu043au0438u043cu0438 u0437u0456u0448u0442u043eu0432u0445u0443u0454u0442u044cu0441u044f u0433u0440u043eu043cu0430u0434u0430,u043du0430u043cu0430u0433u0430u044eu0447u0438u0441u044c u0441u043au043eu0440u0438u0441u0442u0430u0442u0438u0441u044f u0446u0438u043c u0456u043du0441u0442u0440u0443u043cu0435u043du0442u043eu043c.

n

n

n

n
• u041eu0441u043du043eu0432u043du0456 u043fu0440u0438u043du0446u0438u043fu0438 u0442u0430 u043fu0440u043eu0431u043bu0435u043cu0438 u0444u043eu0440u043cu0443u0432u0430u043du043du044f u0442u0430 u0440u0435u0430u043bu0456u0437u0430u0446u0456u0457 u0433u0440u043eu043cu0430u0434u0441u044cu043au043eu0433u043e u0431u044eu0434u0436u0435u0442u0443;

n

• u041fu043eu0442u0440u0435u0431u0438 u0433u0440u043eu043cu0430u0434u0438,u044fu043au0456 u043cu043eu0436u0443u0442u044c u0431u0443u0442u0438 u0432u0438u0440u0456u0448u0435u043du0456 u0437u0430u0432u0434u044fu043au0438 u0431u044eu0434u0436u0435u0442u0443 u0443u0447u0430u0441u0442u0456;

n

• u0414u043eu0441u0432u0456u0434 u0432u0437u0430u0454u043cu043eu0434u0456u0457 u043cu0456u0441u0446u0435u0432u043eu0457 u0432u043bu0430u0434u0438 u0442u0430 u0430u043au0442u0438u0432u0456u0441u0442u0456u0432,u044fu043au0456 u043fu043eu0434u0430u0432u0430u043bu0438 u0441u0432u043eu0457 u043fu0440u043eu0454u043au0442u0438 u043du0430 u0433u0440u043eu043cu0430u0434u0441u044cu043au0435 u0444u0456u043du0430u043du0441u0443u0432u0430u043du043du044f;

n

• u041eu0441u043du043eu0432u043du0456 u043fu0440u043eu0431u043bu0435u043cu0438,u0437 u044fu043au0438u043cu0438 u0434u043eu0432u043eu0434u0438u0442u044cu0441u044f u0437u0456u0448u0442u043eu0432u0445u0443u0432u0430u0442u0438u0441u044f u043fu0440u0438 u0440u0435u0430u043bu0456u0437u0430u0446u0456u0457 u0432u043bu0430u0441u043du0438u0445 u043fu0440u043eu0454u043au0442u0456u0432 u0443 u0425u0435u0440u0441u043eu043du0456,u0456 u0441u043fu0456u043bu044cu043du043e u0448u0443u043au0430u0442u0438u043cu0435u043cu043e u0448u043bu044fu0445u0438 u0457u0445 u043fu043eu0434u043eu043bu0430u043du043du044f.
  n
  n

  n

  n

  u0421u043fu0456u043au0435u0440u0430u043cu0438 u0437u0430u0445u043eu0434u0443 u0431u0443u043bu0438: 

  n

  u0411u043eu0433u0434u0430u043d u0411u0435u0440u043du0430u0446u044cu043au0438u0439,u0435u043au0441u043fu0435u0440u0442 u041eu0444u0456u0441u0443 u043fu0440u043eu0441u0442u0438u0445 u0440u0456u0448u0435u043du044c

  n

  n

  n

  u0410u0431u0441u0430u0432u0430 u041bu044eu0434u043cu0438u043bu0430,u0413u043eu043bu043eu0432u0430 u043fu0440u0430u0432u043bu0456u043du043du044f u0413u041e u0413u043bu043eu0431u0430u043bu044cu043du0438u0438u0306 u043fu043eu0433u043bu044fu0434,u043a.u0435.u043d. u043fu0440u043eu0454u043au0442u043du0430 u043cu0435u043du0435u0434u0436u0435u0440u043au0430,u0435u043au0441u043fu0435u0440u0441u0442u043au0430 u0437 u043fu0430u0440u0442u0438u0441u0438u043fu0430u0446u0456u0456u0308

  n

  n

  n

  u041au0443u0437u044cu043cu0435u043du043au043e u041bu044eu0434u043cu0438u043bu0430,u0413u043eu043bu043eu0432u0430 u041au043eu043eu0440u0434u0438u043du0430u0446u0456u0438u0306u043du043eu0433u043e u043au043eu043cu0456u0442u0435u0442u0443 u0437 u043fu0438u0442u0430u043du044c u0433u0440u043eu043cu0430u0434u0441u044cu043au043eu0433u043e u0431u044eu0434u0436u0435u0442u0443 u0425u0435u0440u0441u043eu043du0430 2018-2020,u043a.u0442.u043d.,u043fu0440u043eu0454u043au0442u043du0430 u043cu0435u043du0435u0434u0436u0435u0440u043au0430,u0435u043au0441u043fu0435u0442u043au0430 u0437 u043fu0430u0440u0442u0438u0441u0438u043fu0430u0446u0456u0456u0308

  n

  n

  n

  u0412u0438u0440u043bu0438u0447 u0404u0432u0433u0435u043du0456u044f,u0430u0432u0442u043eu0440u043au0430 u043fu0440u043eu0454u043au0442u0456u0432 u0413u0411,u0433u043eu043bu043eu0432u043du0430 u0440u0435u0434u0430u043au0442u043eu0440u043au0430 u0456u043du0442u0435u0440u043du0435u0442-u0432u0438u0434u0430u043du043du044f u041au0430vun.City

  n

  n

  n

n

,en:

Democracy Reporting Inteational in cooperation with Vostok SOS held a roudtable table: Problems of formation and implementation of the participatory budget in Kherson which took place on May,31,and was held online. The discussion was dedicated to problems of formation and realization of the participatory budget in Kherson.  

n

Main thematic lines were: 

n

n
• Basic principles and problems of formation and implementation of the participatory budget.

n

• Community needs that can be addressed through a participatory budget.

n

• Experience of interaction between local authorities and activists who submitted their projects for public funding.

n

• The main problems during participatory budget project implementation. 

n

n

Among participants were participants of the participatory budget program of different years,activists, experts,representatives of the local govement body responsible for the participatory budget as well as students of local universities and citizens who registered through an open call.  

n

The discussion started with an overview of the participatory budget instrument by the expert Mr. Bogdan Beatskyi. He spoke about history of its rollout in Ukraine,and it remains one of the only mechanisms at the local level not regulated by any law,making it a completely unique bottom-up initiative.  

n

In Ukraine,the funding available for participatory budget is around 0.28-0.4% of the total budget. The inclusion of citizens in the mechanism is around 4.42%. In Kherson,however,people are more active: 5.6% of inclusion which brings the value of one vote to 588 UAH,around 4 times lower that the country average.  

n

The Kherson situation is quite unique because it was a purely civil society initiative to start a participatory budget. Civil society advocated and pushed for the adoption of the mechanism.  

n

The problems characteristic for the whole country are also present in Kherson. One of the biggest issues of participatory budget is performing the functions of local govement at the expense of the participatory budget,when the financing of municipal institutions is carried out through participatory budget projects. The expert suggested that the mechanism should include filters for such projects that would not allow them to get through. For instance,quotas can be introduced,for example: 50% of the projects are for the whole city,30% are for budget institutions,and 20% are for associations of co-owners of apartment buildings. Another option is to have quotas according to city districts. Finally,criteria of innovation and inclusivity should be introduced and applied during the selection.   

n

The next speaker Ms. Lyudmyla Absava who was among those at the beginning of the initiative,however,says that this is a problem: a purely civic initiative does not have enough ownership in the city govement,therefore,leading to a set of challenges the budget faces.  

n

Among the problems that she named were:  

n

n
• The formation of the coordination council: it should be headed by the local govement representative to provide a sense of ownership; 

n

• Not enough advertising of the competition; 

n

• Implementation of the winning projects is very low – 33% of the projects that won in 2019 are still not implemented: better advocacy with members of local govement should be employed to ensure sufficient funding; 

n

• Insufficient M&E of the participatory budget cycle to provide corrections in the provisions; 

n

• Lack of annual revision of priorities;  

n

n

n
• Reluctance of people to vote online: mobile teams can be organized on the streets to engage these people; the option to vote through BankID should be displayed first,before personal identification option which is more complex for users.  

n

• Some funds from the projects have been redirected towards Covid-19-related costs. 

n

n

Expert Ms. Lyudmyla Kuzmenko who headed the Coordination Committee of the participatory budget noted that Kherson was the last city in the country to adopt the mechanism of participatory budget. The local govement was skeptical about the success of participatory budget,in her opinion,hence making a representative of civil society the head of the committee.  

n

In the first year,the team was not expecting much,and the number of applications highly exceeded the expectations,with 77 applications. 6 projects remain unrealized with no financing. Another problem is that sometimes some projects cannot find a department that would be responsible for the implementation of the project. Also,some of the villages around Kherson that had recently been attached to the city in the process of decentralization were not able to participate. Finally,according to Lyudmyla,the number of members of the coordination committee is too high making it hard to have a quorum and adopt any decisions.  

n

Yevgeniya Virlych who was one of the authors of projects submitted for participatory budget assessed the mechanism and the organized process as positive overall. However,she notes,some of the winning projects get lost after funds were transferred to other causes,and it is the responsibility of the authors to stand their ground to demand their projects to be reinstated in the next cycle. Yevgeniya says that key to success of the project is effective work with stakeholders,beneficiaries of the project as well as a wide promotional campaign.

n

Speakers:

n

n
• Bohdan Beatsky,expert of the Office of Simple Solutions 

n

• Lyudmila Absava,Chairwoman of the Board of the NGO Globalnyi poglyad,expert on civic participation 

n

• Lyudmila Kuzmenko,Head of the Coordination Committee for the Participatory Budget of Kherson 2018-2020,expert on civic participation 

n

• Yevgenia Virlych,author of the participatory budget projects,editor-in-chief of the online publication Kavun.City 

n

• Moderator: Uliana Poltavets,Project Coordinator,DRI 

n

}”